Skip to main content

    Free delivery on orders over £18. Shop Now.

Free delivery on orders over £18

Christopher Montrose Coffee Logo
Speciality Coffee
£0.00 0

Basket

Spend a further £18.00 for free delivery

No products in the basket.

Continue shopping

Coffee Controversy: Is Coffee Good or Bad for You?

…coffee to make you smile
Published 3 May 2024 · Updated 31 October 2026

Coffee has been controversial for about 500 years. It was banned, prescribed as medicine, blamed for impotence, labelled a possible carcinogen and then cleared, and today it’s linked in large studies with a longer life. The arguments continue because coffee is a stimulant, because most of the research is observational, and because a cup of coffee means very different things to different people.

Our short answer: for most healthy adults, the evidence points to moderate coffee drinking doing more good than harm. The history explains a lot, and a few real debates remain.

Why is coffee so controversial?

You would think that after centuries of drinking it, there would be little left to say about whether coffee is good or bad for you. Yet scientists still argue about how much is too much, which benefits are real and which risks matter. Part of the reason is history: coffee arrived in Europe as something closer to a medicine than a drink, so health claims have followed it ever since.

A short history of coffee controversy

Bans in Mecca

One of the earliest recorded rows came in Mecca in 1511, when the governor, Khair Beg, banned coffee and closed coffee houses, worried that they encouraged gossip and dissent. The ban didn’t last; his superiors in Cairo overturned it.

Coffee as medicine in Venice

Turkish merchants brought coffee to Venice, where it was at first sold and prescribed for disorders of the digestive system. That medical framing never quite went away, and every generation since has argued over what coffee does to the body.

London’s coffee houses and the 1674 petition

London’s first coffee house opened in 1652, run by Pasqua Rosée in St Michael’s Alley. Extravagant claims were made for the drink from the start: Rosée’s own handbill promised that it “closeth the orifice of the stomach” and “fortifies the heat within”. Not everyone was convinced. In 1674 The Women’s Petition Against Coffee complained that it made men idle and impotent. A year later Charles II issued a proclamation to suppress coffee houses, which he saw as hotbeds of political gossip. It was so unpopular that it was withdrawn before it came into force.

C. W. Post and the anti-coffee campaign

In the United States, the businessman C. W. Post ran an aggressive advertising campaign warning of coffee’s supposed harms. His motive was less public health than sales: from 1895 his company made Postum, a caffeine-free hot drink made from roasted wheat, bran and molasses, which he wanted people to drink instead.

Does coffee cause cancer?

This is where much of the modern controversy sits. In 1991 the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classed coffee as “possibly carcinogenic to humans”. In 2016, after reviewing more than 1,000 studies, it downgraded coffee to “not classifiable”, meaning the evidence didn’t show it causes cancer. What it did flag was temperature: drinks consumed above 65°C were classed as “probably carcinogenic”, based mainly on studies of very hot tea and maté and oesophageal cancer. Letting your coffee cool a little is sensible either way.

California added another twist. Roasting produces small amounts of acrylamide, and in 2018 a court ruled that coffee sellers there should carry cancer warnings. In 2019 the state’s environmental health agency exempted coffee, concluding that drinking it doesn’t pose a significant cancer risk.

More recently the headlines have swung the other way. A Dutch study of 1,719 people with bowel cancer, published in the International Journal of Cancer in 2024, found that those drinking more than four cups a day had a 32% lower risk of the cancer returning than those drinking fewer than two. It’s an observational study, so it shows a link rather than proof, and the authors called for trials to test it.

How popular is coffee?

None of this has put people off. In the US, the National Coffee Association has reported that 63% of Americans drink coffee daily. In Britain, a 2023 survey by Statista suggested that coffee had overtaken tea as the nation’s regular drink of choice, with around 95 million cups drunk a day. The tea industry, unsurprisingly, begs to differ.

What does the evidence say about the benefits?

The best overview remains a 2017 umbrella review in the BMJ, which pulled together more than 200 meta-analyses. It found that drinking three to four cups a day was associated with the largest reductions in risk across a range of outcomes, including lower all-cause mortality, lower cardiovascular mortality, some cancers, and neurological, metabolic and liver conditions. It concluded that coffee was “more likely to benefit health than to harm it” for most people.

Why might that be? According to the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, coffee contains polyphenols that act as antioxidants and may reduce inflammation, and compounds that may improve the body’s response to insulin, which could explain the lower risk of type 2 diabetes seen in regular drinkers. Many of these compounds are present in decaf too. We cover the subject in more depth in is coffee good for you?

What are the downsides of drinking coffee?

There are real ones, and they mostly come down to caffeine and dose.

  • Sleep and anxiety. Caffeine can cause jitteriness, anxiety and poor sleep, especially in people who are sensitive to it.
  • Blood pressure. Caffeine can raise blood pressure for a short time, and Harvard suggests people who struggle to control their blood pressure may want to moderate their intake.
  • Cholesterol. Unfiltered coffee, such as cafetière or Turkish coffee, contains oils called diterpenes (including cafestol) that can raise LDL cholesterol. Paper-filtered coffee contains almost none.
  • Pregnancy. The BMJ review found that the clearest harms were in pregnancy, including a link with low birth weight. The NHS advises no more than 200 mg of caffeine a day when pregnant.

For healthy adults, the European Food Safety Authority says up to 400 mg of caffeine a day, from all sources, doesn’t raise safety concerns. That’s roughly four mugs of filter coffee, though strength varies a great deal. This isn’t medical advice; if you have a health condition or are pregnant, check with your GP.

Why the arguments rumble on

Most coffee research follows large groups of people over time and looks for patterns. That’s useful, but it can’t fully separate coffee from everything else coffee drinkers do. In older studies, for example, heavy coffee drinkers were also more likely to smoke, which made coffee look worse than it was. People also process caffeine at different speeds, partly because of their genes, so the same cup can affect two people quite differently.

Then there’s the question of what is actually in the cup. A black espresso and a large syrup-laden takeaway drink are both “coffee” in a survey, but they aren’t the same thing nutritionally.

Common questions

Is coffee good or bad for you?

For most healthy adults, moderate drinking (around three to four cups a day) is linked with more benefits than harms. The evidence is mostly observational, and pregnancy is the main exception.

How much caffeine is too much?

EFSA puts the safe limit for healthy adults at 400 mg a day, and the NHS advises 200 mg a day in pregnancy. Sensitivity varies, so if coffee affects your sleep, cut back or stop earlier in the day.

Was coffee ever classed as a carcinogen?

IARC classed it as “possibly carcinogenic” in 1991, then reclassified it as “not classifiable” in 2016. Very hot drinks above 65°C are a separate concern.

Is decaf a good compromise?

For many people, yes. It keeps most of the flavour and many of the polyphenols with very little caffeine. Our Swiss Water Decaf is decaffeinated with water only, with no chemical solvents.

The debate will no doubt carry on. In the meantime, our advice is simple: drink good coffee, in sensible amounts, and enjoy it. If you want a cup that suits any time of day, our Colombian Huila is full and rich without being heavy.

Shop
£0.00 0

Basket

Spend £18+ for FREE delivery

No products in the basket.

Continue shopping
Cart
My Account
25% OFF Your Next Order
Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a 25% off coupon to use on your next order (sale items are excluded). It's a low volume newsletter and you can unsubscribe at anytime.
New subscribers to our newsletter only