Skip to main content

    Free delivery on orders over £18. Shop Now.

Free delivery on orders over £18

Christopher Montrose Coffee Logo
Speciality Coffee
£0.00 0

Basket

Spend a further £18.00 for free delivery

No products in the basket.

Continue shopping

What’s the difference between light, medium and dark coffee roasts?

…coffee to make you smile
Published 13 June 2024 · Updated 31 October 2026

The difference between light, medium and dark roasts is how long and how hot the beans are roasted. Light roasts are taken out around the first crack and keep more of the coffee’s origin flavour and acidity. Medium roasts are more balanced and sweeter. Dark roasts are roasted towards or past the second crack, giving a heavier, more bitter, smoky cup with low acidity. Contrary to popular belief, darker doesn’t mean more caffeine.

If a café has ever asked which roast you’d like and you weren’t sure, this is what they meant.

What happens when coffee is roasted?

Green coffee beans are dense, grassy and not much use for brewing. As they heat up in the roaster, moisture is driven off, sugars caramelise and hundreds of aroma compounds develop. The beans turn from green to yellow, then through shades of brown.

Two audible moments help roasters judge progress:

  • First crack, a popping sound a bit like popcorn, at a bean temperature of around 196 to 202°C. Steam and gas are bursting out of the beans. This is where light roasts end.
  • Second crack, quieter and more of a crackle, at around 224 to 226°C. The structure of the bean is breaking down and oils start moving to the surface. Dark roasts are taken to this point or beyond.

The temperatures are approximate and vary with the roaster and the beans (this roast degree guide gives a useful breakdown). Roasters also control how fast they get there, which matters as much as where they stop.

Light, medium and dark roasts compared

LightMediumMedium-darkDark
ColourLight brown, dry surfaceMedium brown, dry surfaceRich brown, a few spots of oilVery dark brown to almost black, oily
Approximate end temperatureAbout 196 to 205°CAbout 210 to 220°CAbout 220 to 225°CAbout 225 to 240°C
Roast stageAt or just after first crackBetween first and second crackApproaching second crackAt or beyond second crack
FlavourFruity, floral, citrus, sometimes grainy or nuttyCaramel, chocolate, nuts, balancedDark chocolate, spice, toastedSmoky, bittersweet, roasty
BodyLightMediumFullerHeavy but can feel thin if very dark
AcidityHighMediumLow to mediumLow
CaffeineMuch the same across all roasts (see below)

Light roasts

Light roasts are roasted for the shortest time at the lowest temperatures, finishing at or shortly after first crack. They keep far more of the bean’s own character, so you taste where the coffee came from: the fruit of a washed Ethiopian, the citrus of a high-grown Central American.

In that sense, light roasts have the most distinctive flavour, even though the cup feels lighter. They can taste bright, fruity and floral, and sometimes nutty or grainy if they’re very light. Lighter roasts also keep more of the bean’s chlorogenic acids, which break down as roasting goes on.

Medium roasts

The longer coffee is roasted, the more of its original acidity gives way to roast flavours. Medium roasts sit in the sweet spot. They are roasted for longer and hotter than light roasts, finishing after first crack but before second crack. Acidity is softer, sweetness comes forward, and caramel, chocolate and nut flavours develop.

Medium is the most popular roast level, and it’s the most versatile. Our Fairtrade Brazil is medium roasted to bring out its smooth, delicate nature and sweet fruit, and our Espresso Smile blend is a medium roast too, with malty sweetness, toasted almonds and a long milk chocolate finish.

Medium-dark and dark roasts

Dark roasts go to the second crack or a little beyond. The beans lose more moisture, oils rise to the surface, and roast flavours take over from origin flavours. The result is bittersweet and smoky, with low acidity and, at its best, a deep, comforting richness. Pushed too far, it simply tastes burnt.

Medium-dark is the halfway house, and it’s the classic Italian espresso style. Our Espresso Grin is roasted medium-dark for a rich, earthy, punchy cup with full body and low acidity. It cuts through milk well.

Dark roasts are often said to be gentler on the stomach because they taste less acidic. Some people do find them easier to drink, but responses vary.

Does dark roast have more caffeine?

No, and the reverse isn’t really true either. Caffeine is very stable during roasting, so a bean keeps almost all of it. What changes is weight and density: dark roasted beans lose more moisture, so they are lighter and larger.

That leads to a small twist. Measured by weight, darker roasts can contain slightly more caffeine, because you need more beans to make up the same number of grams. Measured by the scoop, the difference shrinks considerably. Data reported by Sprudge found a difference of about 9% by volume. In practice, how much coffee you use, the species (robusta has about twice the caffeine of arabica) and how you brew matter far more than the roast. If you want more of a kick, pick a stronger recipe, not a darker roast.

Which roast suits which brew method?

Brew methodRoasts that work well
Pour over and filterLight and medium, to show off clarity and sweetness
AeroPressAny, adjust the recipe to suit
CafetièreMedium and medium-dark for body
Espresso, blackMedium for sweetness and brightness
Espresso with milkMedium-dark and dark to cut through the milk
Moka potMedium-dark and dark
Cold brewMedium and darker, for chocolatey, low-acid results

These are starting points. A good light roast can make a superb espresso, and a medium-dark coffee can be lovely through a filter. If you’re choosing a filter method, our comparison of pour over and drip brew may help.

Our coffees by roast and style

  • Medium: Fairtrade Brazil and Espresso Smile, sweet and balanced.
  • Medium-dark: Espresso Grin, rich and punchy, our Italian-style espresso.
  • Single origins with character: Colombian Huila, full and rich but delicate, and the rest of our single estates and origins.
  • For filter: Drip Brew Special, sweet and malty, blended to resemble Jamaican Blue Mountain.

If you like a bold, full-bodied cup, our strong coffee collection brings those together.

Quick answers

Which roast is strongest?

It depends what you mean. Dark roasts taste strongest in a roasty, bitter way. Light roasts have the most distinctive origin flavour. Caffeine is much the same across roasts.

Is light roast more acidic?

It tastes brighter and more acidic, yes. Good acidity is pleasant, like the tang of a ripe apple, not sourness. For more on this, read our guide to coffee acidity.

Why are some beans oily?

Oils move to the surface as roasting approaches and passes second crack, so oily beans are usually medium-dark or dark. Very oily beans can clog some bean-to-cup grinders.

What roast is best for beginners?

Medium. It’s balanced, familiar and works with almost any brew method, which makes it an easy place to start before exploring either way.

If you can’t decide, start with the Fairtrade Brazil. It’s clean, mild and sweet, and it makes a good cup however you brew it.

Shop
£0.00 0

Basket

Spend £18+ for FREE delivery

No products in the basket.

Continue shopping
Cart
My Account
25% OFF Your Next Order
Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a 25% off coupon to use on your next order (sale items are excluded). It's a low volume newsletter and you can unsubscribe at anytime.
New subscribers to our newsletter only