Skip to main content

    Free delivery on orders over £18. Shop Now.

Free delivery on orders over £18

Christopher Montrose Coffee Logo
Speciality Coffee
£0.00 0

Basket

Spend a further £18.00 for free delivery

No products in the basket.

Continue shopping

What is a Q Grader? How coffee is scored and graded

…coffee to make you smile
Published 17 June 2022 · Updated 31 October 2026

A Q Grader is a coffee taster licensed to assess and score coffee to an agreed international standard, much as a sommelier assesses wine. The Q stands for quality. Q Graders cup coffee, score it on a 100-point scale and identify defects, and their scores are what decide whether a coffee can be called speciality: 80 points or more.

The qualification is demanding, internationally recognised and, as of late 2025, run by a different organisation from the one that founded it.

Who runs the Q Grader programme?

The Q programme was created by the Coffee Quality Institute (CQI), an American not-for-profit founded in 1996 to improve the quality of coffee and the lives of the people who produce it. The first Q Grader courses ran in 2004, and for around two decades CQI ran the programme in partnership with the Specialty Coffee Association, whose cupping protocol and scoring form the graders used. Separate qualifications covered Arabica (the Q Arabica Grader) and Robusta.

In April 2025 the two organisations announced that the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) would take over the Q Grader programme from 1 October 2025. CQI is no longer involved in running it. The SCA has rebuilt the course around its newer Coffee Value Assessment (CVA), introduced in 2023, and calls the result the evolved Q Grader. Existing Q Grader certificates stay valid until their expiry date, and qualified graders were offered a fast-track route through a short CVA course (SCA Q Grader programme).

The change was not universally popular, and debate in the industry about cost, access and how coffee should be scored continues. For coffee buyers, the practical effect so far is small: Q Graders still cup and score coffee, and the 80-point line still marks speciality.

The 100-point scale and what the scores mean

Under the traditional SCA cupping form, a coffee is scored across attributes such as fragrance and aroma, flavour, aftertaste, acidity, body, balance, sweetness, uniformity and clean cup, with deductions for defects. The total lands on a 100-point scale.

ScoreGrade
90 to 100Outstanding
85 to 89.99Excellent
80 to 84.99Very good (speciality)
Below 80Not speciality grade

In practice, most speciality coffee you will find in shops scores in the low to mid 80s. Coffees above 90 are rare, often tiny lots sold at auction. The CVA keeps a 100-point quality score but separates it from descriptive tasting notes and information about the coffee’s origin and certifications, on the reasoning that a single number never told the whole story. We explain how the score relates to what is in your cup in our guide to speciality coffee.

What does the Q Grader exam involve?

It’s a hard qualification to pass. Under CQI, candidates sat a six-day course and exam made up of around 22 tests, and many needed retakes. The tests included:

  • Cupping: scoring flights of six coffees, with scores checked against those of experienced graders.
  • Olfactory tests: identifying 36 aromas commonly found in coffee, some blind.
  • Organic acid matching: recognising the different acids found in coffee, such as citric, malic, acetic and phosphoric, in matched pairs.
  • Sensory skills: judging the intensity of sweet, salty and sour solutions on their own and mixed together.
  • Triangulation: picking the odd cup out from sets of three.
  • Green grading: counting and classifying defects in samples of unroasted coffee.
  • Roasted sample identification: spotting roast faults in sample roasts.
  • General knowledge: 100 multiple-choice questions on growing, harvesting, processing, roasting, grading and cupping.

The SCA’s evolved course also runs over six days, with two days given to physical assessment of coffee and four to sensory assessment using the CVA. Courses run in many countries, in both coffee-producing and coffee-drinking nations. If you want to try something gentler first, the SCA suggests its introductory cupping workshop.

Why Q Graders matter to coffee buyers

Coffee is traded across continents, often between people who never meet. A shared standard means a score given by a cupper in Colombia means much the same thing to an importer in London or a roaster anywhere in the UK. That matters for three reasons.

Price

Scores feed directly into what a farmer is paid. A coffee scoring 86 can command a much higher price than one scoring 82, and well above commodity coffee. A credible score gives producers proof of quality to negotiate with.

Consistency

Roasters buying from samples need to know the coffee that arrives will match the one they tasted. Trained graders check both.

Trust

For people drinking the coffee, a score is a shorthand for care taken at every stage. It doesn’t tell you whether you will like it, but it does tell you it’s free of defects and has been judged good by people who taste thousands of cups a year.

We took a similar approach when building our own range. Chris and Monty carried out more than 5,500 tastings across farms, exporters, importers, roasters and baristas, and chose fewer than ten coffees from them. Our article on why it’s worth spending more on coffee explains where that extra money goes.

Common questions

Is a Q Grader the same as a barista?

No. A barista prepares and serves coffee. A Q Grader evaluates and scores coffee, usually green coffee being bought and sold. Some people are both.

How many Q Graders are there?

More than 8,000 people have been certified through the programme worldwide, according to Daily Coffee News.

Does a high score mean I will like the coffee?

Not necessarily. Scores reward clarity, complexity and an absence of faults. If you love a rich, low-acid cup with milk, an 84-point Brazil may suit you better than a 90-point Ethiopian.

What does “cupping” mean?

Cupping is the standard tasting method: coarse grounds steeped in hot water in a bowl, the crust broken, then the coffee slurped from a spoon. Our A to Z of coffee terms covers more of the jargon.

If you want to taste a carefully sourced single origin, try our Colombian Huila, from smallholder lots in Huila and Tolima. Brew it as filter and taste it black first; then add milk and see how it changes.

Shop
£0.00 0

Basket

Spend £18+ for FREE delivery

No products in the basket.

Continue shopping
Cart
My Account
25% OFF Your Next Order
Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a 25% off coupon to use on your next order (sale items are excluded). It's a low volume newsletter and you can unsubscribe at anytime.
New subscribers to our newsletter only